Spanish Language Learning – I’m a beginner, and this is how I understand the difference between “Estar” and “Ser”. Please correct me if I’m wrong here.

Ser = To be

Estar = To be in a state of (easy to remember e**sta**r, **sta**te

“Ser” is used for when you are describing long-term or even permanent characteristics of a noun (object, person or place) or verb. Also think of “ser” as when you’re describing **facts** about something, or a characteristic that isn’t changed by its surroundings. The fact that it’s Thursday may be temporary, but it’s a fact that is true regardless. Nothing can change that it’s Thursday; the day of the week isn’t a state of being.

Eres joven

Ella es inteligente

Esta clase es muy aburrida

Creo que correr es bastante divertido

Las mesas son rojas

None of these are “states” that the objects or verbs are in.

You’re young, but you’re not young “for now”, it’s going to be a very long time before you’re old. It would be slightly odd in English to say “You’re young… for now”.

She is intelligent, but it’s a part of her as a person. She’s not just intelligent “for the time being”.

This class is boring, but it’s not just in a state of being boring. I phrase it as a fact because that’s just how I think it is. This class is very boring.

I think that running is quite fun. Not just some runs that I go on, but all runs at all times. I think it’s a fun activity in general. Again, since it’s my opinion, I state it as an unchanging fact. Value your opinions!

The tables are red. They’re not just red “at this moment”, since I don’t have any plans to paint them. You’re describing a fact about the tables

“Ser” is also used before other nouns. This is more to point out _what_ an object or person is, not necessarily describe it.

Soy un médico

Ella es una fanática de Britney Spears

Sure, I could quite my job as a doctor, but we’re describing _what_ I am. Same applies for the Britney Spears fan.

“Estar” is for a state something is in. It can be real and factual, but it’s not necessarily a fact about the object in particular. If you isolated that object from its environment, would it still be in that state? The state an object is in is caused by its surroundings.

Estoy triste

La montaña está a la derecha del lago

Mi madre esta orgullosa de mi

Estamos jugando un videojuego

I’m sad, but it’s just a state I’m in. I’m not necessarily a “sad” person in general.

The mountain is to the right of the lake, but it’s not a fact about the mountain itself. It’s a fact about how the mountain relates to its environment and the objects around it. Remove the lake, and the statement is no longer true.

My mum is proud of me probably because of something I’ve done. She’s not necessarily a proud person in general.

We’re playing a videogame right now. It’s a state we’re all in.

Swapping “ser” for “estar” can completely change the meaning for these reasons:

“Estoy molesto” means “I’m annoyed” or “I’m bothered”

But if we swap that for “Soy molesto”, it means “I am **annoying**” or “I am **bothersome**”. It now describes a fact about what I’m like as a person, instead of a state of emotion.

“Estoy molesto porque mi hermano es molesto” literally means “I’m annoyed because my brother is annoying”.

Please tell me if I got anything wrong.

View Reddit by BilingualThrowaway01View Source

First Sentences for Toddlers | Learn to Talk | Toddler Speech Delay | Speech Practice Video English
Chinese Language Learning – 台灣中文 Taiwan-style Mandarin Learning Resources that helped me
Vocabulary about FAMILY for children – Family tree for kids
Spanish Language Learning – Struggling with direct and indirect object pronouns. HELP!
Practise English at home with this technique/ Start Speaking English / Fastest way to learn English
English Listening Practice || English Conversation || Slow and Easy English Lesson
Alphabet ABC | Learn and Practice Phonic Sounds | English Pronunciation Course
Sleep and learn English for Myanmar people(Myanmar)(Part-1)(Words about Relations)
Common Chinese Sentence Structures for Speaking Mandarin in Daily Life – Beginner Chinese Lessons
Chinese Language Learning – 台灣中文 Taiwan-style Mandarin Learning Resources that helped me
Conversational Chinese Dialogues for Everyday Life — Beginners to Intermediates
Chinese Language Learning – My language learning progress so far – 6 weeks in
Maximum Spanish you can learn in 15 minutes
Learn Spanish While Sleeping
Spanish Language Learning – Struggling with direct and indirect object pronouns. HELP!
i made a sandwich | 🇪🇸 SPANISH VLOG for Spanish Learners! (w/ subtitles!)