Chinese Language Learning – Seeking comments/feedback on my own translation of Qing Dynasty poem《洞仙歌·珊珊琐骨》by 吴藻 (Wu Zao)

Hi all! Yesterday, I posted on this sub asking for help locating the text of this Chinese poem, and you immediately helped me find it! <3 I then spent the day building my own translation, with the aid of lots of googling and Google Translate. My Chinese language skills are around an intermediate level — decent but not fluent.

I would love to receive any comments/feedback/discussion on the accuracy of my translation. (In the translation, I am primarily aiming for accurate literal meaning, and not as much for poetic style. However, I am definitely interested in understanding any double-meanings, word play, hidden connotations, or other poetic devices that a fluent speaker would pick up on better than me).


The original Chinese text:



My translation:

>Shimmering collarbones, seemingly a mystical being from a jade city. With one smile we met and I forgot how to speak.
>Gently we picked flowers and rested against bamboo, the cold dew collected on your blue-green sleeves. Inside that empty valley, I faced your ruminations.
>While the orchid lamp flickered dimly, we drank wine, read poetry, then sang a song of heartbreak from Jiangnan.
>We are equally matched in talent, I’m driven crazy, yes I want to bear this, if my beloved consents.
>It’s perfectly misty, springtime fog rises from five lakes, I’m going to buy a red boat, carry you away with me.


Specific questions I have:

1. The character 珊 means coral. However, when it is repeated twice (珊珊 ) does this mean “coral-like” or have any literal association with coral? Or does 珊珊 simply refer to a general shimmery/shining appearance?
2. 幽绪 — the definitions I’ve found online say this means something like a deep contemplative mental state. I am having trouble picking a good English translation to capture this word. So far, I have gone with “rumination.” But are there any hidden connotations that I am missing? For instance, is there an emotional association? (Does it usually refer to a sad feeling of brooding, or is it emotionally neutral?)
3. The three characters 扫眉才 literally mean eyebrow-painting talent. But according to Google the four character phrase 扫眉才子 is an idiom that refers to other talents, such as literary talent. Should I interpret 扫眉才 in this poem as a shortening/abbreviation of the idiom, or should I interpret it as literally talking about painting eyebrows? Overall, I don’t feel very confident in my translation of the phrase “一样扫眉才”.
4. In the last line, the character 正 is causing me confusion. According to Google Translate, it means “straight” or “upright” or “correct.” I am not totally sure how that makes sense in the context of the poem. I ended up translating the character 正 as “perfect” or “perfectly,” but I am not really sure if that is fair.


Other comments are welcome and appreciated too! Thank you so much. <3 <3 <3

View Reddit by grace_moon_zaoView Source


  1. Illustrious-Bus-3840 July 12, 2022
  2. hanguitarsolo July 12, 2022
  3. cela_ July 12, 2022
  4. syzhk3 July 12, 2022
ESL Speaking and Listening Activity: Typhoon | A fun ESL review game for all ages
Chinese Language Learning – Cartoons in Mandarin
I like fruit | ESL Music Video for Kids
10 Summer Classroom Activities and Games – Great for ESL Lessons!
Learn english with asmae lesson 1 – 7 : أول خطوة لك في تعلم اللغة الإنجليزية من الصفر باسلوب جديد
Improve your English in 30 days with this ACTION PLAN
(Reading Practice (Improve your pronunciation in English
learn english through stories 🔥 Amazing Thinkers
What's BILLION in Chinese?
Chinese Language Learning – Cartoons in Mandarin
Beginner Mandarin Chinese: "If You Love Me, Marry Me" with eChineseLearning
Chinese Language Learning – Things that puzzle me as a heritage speaker
Learning Spanish thru songs. "Welcome – Bienvenidos". Bilingual song for kids. La Vida en Español.
Learning Spanish👌#spanishvocabulary #spanish #spanishforbeginners #spanishdrill #learnspanish
Learn Spanish or Vanish Episodio Uno/One
Build a Memory Palace to Learn Spanish | Learning Strategies